(AP Photo/HO/Fox)
We loves us some Barry Gibb. However, we didn't love Barry Gibb night on "American Idol." Maybe it was because of the phoned-in performances or simply because it was the first time contestants sang two songs in one night. Whatever the reason, we were more interested in watching Billy Ray Cyrus getting the boot on "Dancing with the Stars" — he's like the Sanjaya over there, if you're not familiar — than the Final Four's ZZZzzz-worthy performances. At this point in the game, The Slug is extremely conflicted on who to vote for, you know, if we actually voted. Bear with us as we work through our feelings. And let us know who you love at theslug@ap.org.
Melinda Dootlittle. Yes, the girl can sing. Yes, she's consistent. No, we don't want her to win. There's a reason she's been a backup singer for so long. She's safe, dependable and devoid of any kind of diva or rock-star attitude. We don't need to witness her destroying a hotel room, but we'd like to see her at least talk back to Simon Cowell.
LaKisha Jones. When she's on stage and just ripping it up with that big ol' voice of hers, she's amazing. However, she's never seemed comfortable with herself in this crazy competition. Just once, we'd like to see her do something completely nuts. Unlike Doolittle, we think Jones is capable of it. And we like that.
Blake Lewis. Oh, Blakey. We love you. We hate you. We're not
sure if you should become an "Idol" or you should go back to beatboxing
in the back of an electronics store in Washington. You reek of class clown cheesiness, but it's strangely self-aware and comforting. This ain't a personality contest though, it's "Idol." Whatever that means.
Jordin Sparks. When we're watching "Idol" and Sparks comes on screen, we usually have one of two reactions: "Can't believe she's only 17 years old!" or "Can't believe she's so much taller than Ryan Seacrest!" Of all the contestants, Sparks is probably the most readymade pop star. She has a long life — to be manufactured — ahead of her.